产品选型
Product model
Current location:

How to Check the Accuracy Grade of Temperature Sensors? Standard Interpretation and Practical Selection Guide

Number of Views:1292026-10-16 10:27:43

The measurement accuracy of temperature sensors is the core indicator that determines the reliability of temperature control systems, and also one of the most concerned parameters during procurement and selection. However, many practitioners only stay on the nominal ±℃ value when understanding accuracy grades, ignoring the applicable conditions, test standards and working condition impacts of accuracy. This leads to either blindly pursuing high accuracy and pushing up costs, or selecting an accuracy grade that does not match the actual working conditions, resulting in measurement deviation, control failure and other problems. Correctly interpreting the definition, standard boundaries and influencing factors of accuracy grades is the premise for reasonable selection and ensuring temperature measurement effects. This paper systematically expands from four dimensions: basic concepts of accuracy, accuracy standards of mainstream products, actual influencing factors, and selection principles, and provides a clear reference framework for accuracy selection in various scenarios combined with industry application experience.

1. Core Concepts and Expressions of Temperature Sensor Accuracy

To understand accuracy grades, we must first distinguish different error expression forms to avoid conceptual confusion:

1. Absolute Error: The difference between the measured value and the true temperature, in ℃. It is the most intuitive expression of accuracy. For example, ±0.5℃ means the deviation between the measurement result and the true value does not exceed 0.5℃. Absolute error usually corresponds to a specific temperature range, and it is meaningless to talk about absolute error without the range.

2. Relative Error: The ratio of absolute error to the measured true temperature, expressed as a percentage. For example, ±0.5% is mostly used for accuracy description in the high temperature section. The higher the temperature, the larger the allowable value of absolute deviation.

3. Reference Error: The ratio of absolute error to the full range of the sensor, expressed as a percentage. For example, ±0.2%FS is a common accuracy grade expression form for industrial instruments, and the maximum absolute error in the full range is converted according to the full range.

4. Accuracy Grade: It is a grade that divides the measurement error of sensors according to national or industry standards. It is a standardized calibration for product accuracy consistency, representing the upper error limit of products under specified conditions.

It should be clarified that all nominal accuracies are based on standard test conditions, including ambient temperature, installation method, calibration equipment, etc. The actual accuracy in use is often different from the nominal value, which needs to be evaluated in combination with working conditions.

2. Accuracy Grade Standards for Mainstream Temperature Sensors

Temperature sensors with different principles follow different accuracy standards, with different grade divisions and applicable ranges, which are the core basis for selection:

2.1 Accuracy Grades of NTC Thermistors

The accuracy of NTC thermistors is usually determined by the resistance tolerance and B value tolerance at 25℃. The industry is conventionally divided into four grades:

· High Precision Grade: ±0.1℃ (at 25℃), B value tolerance ±0.5%. It is mainly used in scenarios with extremely high accuracy requirements such as medical equipment, precision testing instruments, and metrology calibration, with relatively high cost.

· Precision Grade: ±0.2℃, B value tolerance ±1%. It is suitable for scenarios such as new energy battery management, high-end home appliance temperature control, and industrial precision control, and is the mainstream choice balancing accuracy and cost.

· Standard Grade: ±0.5℃, B value tolerance ±1%~±2%. It is widely used in scenarios such as ordinary home appliances, consumer electronics, and general industrial temperature control, with outstanding cost performance and the largest usage.

· General Grade: ±1℃ and above, B value tolerance ±3%. It is mostly used for overheat protection and rough temperature measurement scenarios with low accuracy requirements, with obvious cost advantages.

The accuracy of NTC has obvious temperature interval characteristics: it performs best in the range of -10℃~100℃, and the error will gradually increase after deviating from this range. When selecting, we should focus on the accuracy in the actual working temperature range rather than the nominal value at room temperature.

2.2 Accuracy Grades of Platinum RTDs (PT100/PT1000)

Platinum RTDs follow the IEC 60751 international standard and GB/T 30121 national standard, and are divided into three grades: AA, A and B according to accuracy. Different grades correspond to error limits in different temperature zones:

· Grade AA: ±(0.1℃ + 0.0017|t|), with the highest accuracy in the range of -50℃~250℃. It is mostly used in scenarios such as metrology standards, laboratory calibration, and precision industrial control.

· Grade A: ±(0.15℃ + 0.002|t|), which is the mainstream accuracy grade in the industrial field, suitable for scenarios with high accuracy requirements such as process control, medical equipment, and food processing.

· Grade B: ±(0.3℃ + 0.005|t|), whose accuracy meets the needs of general industrial control, with moderate cost, and is a common grade for conventional industrial temperature measurement.

The accuracy of platinum RTDs changes linearly with temperature. The absolute error is small in the low temperature section and gradually increases in the high temperature section. The overall linearity is better than that of NTC thermistors.

2.3 Accuracy Grades of Thermocouples

Thermocouples follow the IEC 60584 standard and are divided into Grade I and Grade II according to accuracy. Different calibration numbers have different error limits: Taking the most commonly used Type K thermocouple as an example:

· Grade I: In the range of -40℃~1000℃, the error is ±1.5℃ or ±0.4%|t|, whichever is larger. It is suitable for precision industrial temperature measurement, temperature calibration and other scenarios.

· Grade II: In the range of -40℃~1200℃, the error is ±2.5℃ or ±0.75%|t|, whichever is larger. It is a conventional grade for industrial high-temperature measurement, suitable for general high-temperature control scenarios such as drying rooms, furnaces and heat treatment.

The overall accuracy of thermocouples is lower than that of platinum RTDs and NTC, but in the high temperature range above 300℃, it is the only cost-effective temperature measurement solution, and its accuracy is relatively improved with the increase of temperature.

3. Key Factors Affecting Actual Measurement Accuracy

The nominal accuracy grade is an indicator under ideal conditions. The actual accuracy in use is affected by multiple factors, which is also the core reason why many users feel that "the measured accuracy is not as good as the nominal value":

1. Influence of Temperature Measurement Range: The accuracy of all sensors corresponds to a specific temperature range, and the error will increase significantly beyond the optimal working range. For example, an NTC with ±0.1℃ at room temperature may have an error of more than ±2℃ at 200℃; the error of Grade B PT100 at -200℃ low temperature will also be significantly higher than that at room temperature.

2. Calibration Method and Points: Single-point calibration can only guarantee the accuracy near the calibration temperature point, while multi-point segmented calibration can ensure the accuracy consistency within the full range. Some low-priced products only perform room temperature single-point calibration, and the actual error in the working temperature range will be much larger than the nominal value.

3. Installation and Heat Conduction Error: Insufficient contact between the probe and the measured medium, unreasonable installation position, and excessive heat loss of the probe will cause the measured value to deviate from the true temperature. For example, insufficient insertion depth of the probe during pipeline temperature measurement will cause significant systematic error, which has nothing to do with the accuracy grade of the sensor itself.

4. Lead Wire and Circuit Error: The resistance signals of NTC and platinum RTDs are easily affected by lead wire resistance. The lead wire resistance of two-wire PT100 will be directly superimposed on the measurement result, causing positive deviation; electromagnetic interference during long-distance wiring will also lead to signal distortion and reduce actual measurement accuracy.

5. Long-term Stability and Drift: After long-term use, component aging will lead to resistance drift and gradual decline in accuracy. Harsh working conditions such as high temperature and corrosion will accelerate the aging process. The annual drift of high-quality products can be controlled within 0.1℃, while inferior products may exceed 0.5℃ per year.

4. Selection Principles and Scenario Matching of Accuracy Grades

When selecting, higher accuracy is not always better. It needs to be comprehensively considered in combination with actual needs, working conditions and cost budget, following the following core principles:

4.1 Select on Demand to Avoid Accuracy Redundancy

High accuracy means higher cost. For example, the price of NTC with ±0.1℃ is 3~5 times that of ±0.5℃. For scenarios such as ordinary home appliance overheat protection and ambient temperature monitoring, the accuracy of ±0.5℃~±1℃ fully meets the demand. Blindly selecting high accuracy grades will only cause unnecessary cost waste.

4.2 Focus on Working Temperature Zone Instead of Nominal Accuracy

Focus on the error in the actual working temperature range, not the nominal accuracy at room temperature. For example, in scenarios where the working temperature range is 100℃~200℃, priority should be given to inspecting the actual error in this interval rather than the nominal value at 25℃. If necessary, manufacturers can be required to provide calibration data for the corresponding temperature zone.

4.3 Combine Working Conditions and Reserve Error Margin

Under harsh working conditions, factors such as installation, environmental interference and aging will bring additional errors. When selecting, a certain accuracy margin should be reserved. For example, a system requiring control accuracy of ±1℃ should select a sensor with nominal accuracy of ±0.5℃ to offset the additional error caused by working conditions.

4.4 Reference of Accuracy Grades for Different Scenarios

· Home Appliances and Consumer Electronics: ±0.5℃ grade NTC for ordinary temperature control, ±0.2℃ grade NTC for high-end precision temperature control;

· New Energy Battery Management: Priority is given to high-precision NTC of ±0.2℃~±0.5℃ grade to ensure the accurate implementation of BMS temperature control strategy;

· General Industrial Process Control: Grade B PT100 or Grade II Type K thermocouple can meet the demand;

· Precision Industry and Metrology: Grade A/AA PT100 or ±0.1℃ grade NTC, combined with multi-point calibration.

5. Manufacturer Capability for Accuracy Guarantee: Dongguan Jingpin Electronics Co., Ltd.

The actual accuracy of temperature sensors depends not only on the components themselves, but also on the manufacturer's sorting ability, calibration level and quality control system. As a professional manufacturer deeply engaged in the field of temperature sensing, Dongguan Jingpin Electronics Co., Ltd. has established a perfect accuracy control system, which can provide NTC thermistors and temperature sensor products of various accuracy grades to accurately match the accuracy needs of different scenarios. In the chip sorting link, Jingpin Electronics adopts high-precision automatic sorting equipment to conduct full inspection and grading on the resistance and B value of NTC chips, with the grading accuracy up to milliohm level, ensuring that the parameters of each chip meet the requirements of the corresponding accuracy grade, and guaranteeing the product accuracy consistency from the source. Compared with manufacturers with manual sampling sorting, products with full inspection sorting have lower parameter dispersion and better batch consistency. In the calibration and testing link, Jingpin Electronics has professional metrology equipment such as standard constant temperature baths and high-low temperature calibration chambers, which can realize multi-point segmented calibration in the range of -50℃~300℃. Each product undergoes multi-temperature zone accuracy testing before leaving the factory, and corresponding test data is issued to ensure that the nominal accuracy is consistent with the actual performance. For customers' specific working temperature zones, customized calibration services can also be provided to optimize the measurement accuracy in the target temperature zone. In terms of product system, Jingpin Electronics covers all grades of NTC thermistors from general grade to high precision grade, and also supports multi-category sensors such as platinum RTDs and thermocouples. It can provide selection suggestions according to customers' working conditions and accuracy needs, helping customers find the best balance between accuracy and cost. For special accuracy requirements, customized parameter design and calibration schemes can be provided to meet the precise temperature measurement needs of non-standard scenarios. In addition, the technical team of Jingpin Electronics can assist customers in troubleshooting error sources in installation, wiring and other links, optimize temperature measurement schemes, and ensure the final temperature measurement effect of the system, rather than simply providing products.

All in all, to correctly view the accuracy grade of temperature sensors, we must not only understand the standard definition and grade division, but also evaluate the actual use accuracy in combination with actual working conditions. Selecting on demand and reserving margin can achieve the optimal balance between performance and cost. Dongguan Jingpin Electronics will continue to improve accuracy control technology and provide reliable temperature measurement solutions for customers in various industries with stable product quality and professional technical support.

Contact us

Dongguan Jingpin Electronic Technology Co., Ltd

Tel:086-769-86068888

Fax:086-769-88770899

Email:sales@jpet.cn

Address: 8F, building F1, Tianan Digital City, No.1, Huangjin Road, Nancheng District, Dongguan City

Copyright 2020 Dongguan Jingpin Electronic Technology Co., Ltd copyright All Rights Reserved

Website filing:粤ICP备10083821号